Why salary calculators disagree — and how to get your real net
Two salary calculators can give net pay that differs by hundreds of francs a month. Here is which assumptions cause it, with numbers from one example.
Every figure on this page is an estimate computed by the site from the cited data files. Your payslip and the cantonal tax office have the final word.
The short answer
Calculators disagree because they guess different things about you. The law fixes the AHV, IV, EO and ALV rates. It does not fix your pension fund plan, your accident insurer's rate, how many payments you get, or how your canton withholds tax. Each calculator fills those gaps with its own default.
In our example, the guesses about the pension fund, accident insurance and payments alone move the yearly net by up to CHF 2'287. Whether tax is withheld moves the payslip net by much more. No calculator is wrong to make a guess. But only your own contract and payslip remove it.
To get your real net, replace each guess with your own figure. The list at the end shows where to find each one.
One example, six assumptions
We start from one case: Zurich, CHF 100'000 gross a year, single, no children, taxed at source. Then we change one assumption at a time. The site's engine computes every row from the 2026 data.
| Assumption (one change from the base case) | Net per year (estimate) | Net per regular month (estimate) | Difference from the base case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base case: BVG legal minimum, NBU 0.9%, equal monthly payments, withholding | CHF 80'537 | CHF 6'711 | — |
| Pension fund with a richer plan (the engine’s enveloping plan) | CHF 78'750 | CHF 6'563 | −CHF 1'787 |
| NBU at 0.4% | CHF 81'037 | CHF 6'753 | +CHF 500 |
| NBU at 1.4% | CHF 80'037 | CHF 6'670 | −CHF 500 |
| Same gross with one extra month’s pay | CHF 80'005 | CHF 6'237 | −CHF 532 |
| Taxed ordinarily: nothing withheld on the payslip (tax paid later) | CHF 89'487 | CHF 7'457 | +CHF 8'950 |
The base case uses common default assumptions. The other rows are all realistic. Here is why each one moves the result.
Pension fund (BVG)
The law sets only a minimum. Contributions start above an entry threshold of CHF 22'680. A coordination deduction of CHF 26'460 comes off the salary first. The age credit is then a share of what remains, rising with age. Employer and employee share it, as set in the BVG.
Many employers offer more. Some skip the coordination deduction. Some insure salary above CHF 90'720. Some split the cost differently. A calculator that assumes the minimum shows a higher net than a richer plan pays. The pension fund line on your payslip is the only reliable figure.
Non-occupational accident insurance (NBU)
Every insurer sets its own NBU rate. Calculators commonly use a range from 0.4% to 1.4% of salary up to CHF 148'200. That is a spread, not a rule. Your payslip shows the rate your employer's insurer charges.
Monthly pay, with or without an extra month
The same annual gross can be paid in equal monthly instalments, or with one extra month's pay on top. The yearly net is almost the same. The regular month is not: with the extra month, each normal month is smaller. A calculator that asks for your monthly pay and assumes no extra payment will understate your year if you actually get one.
Withholding tax or ordinary taxation
At source, tax comes off every payslip. With ordinary taxation, nothing is withheld and you pay later on your tax return. So two calculators that assume different cases show very different "net" figures for the same person. In our example the withholding is about CHF 8'950 a year. The tax does not disappear under ordinary taxation. You owe it later, so set that money aside.
The canton's model
Cantons withhold in one of two ways, set out in the ESTV circular no. 45. In the monthly model, each month's pay is taxed at the rate for that month's amount. A 13th salary in December pushes December into a higher rate. In the annual model, the canton uses the yearly income to set the rate. December is no different from the other months.
| Canton | Model | Rate, regular month | Rate, December with the extra month’s pay | Withholding per year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zurich | monthly | 8.4% | 15.43% | CHF 9'482 |
| Geneva | annual | 13.31% | 13.31% | CHF 13'310 |
The ESTV overview lists the model of every canton. A calculator that ignores the model can still get the year right but get December badly wrong.
How to get your real net
Take your contract and one recent payslip. Then replace each guess:
- Pension fund: copy the BVG line from your payslip, or the plan from your pension certificate.
- NBU: read the rate on your payslip.
- Payments: check whether your contract includes an extra month's pay.
- Tax: look for a withholding tax line and its code.
- Canton: use the canton where you live. If you live abroad, use your employer's canton, usually where you work (federal direct tax act, DBG Art. 107).
Our net salary calculator asks for each of these. When you answer "don't know", it shows a range instead of hiding the guess. You can also check the withholding tax on a payslip.
Caveats
- Every figure on this page is an estimate from the site's engine. It is not a payslip.
- The example is one profile. Your own spread can be larger or smaller.
- Ordinary taxation depends on deductions and on your commune. The table shows only what leaves your payslip.
Official sources
- Federal law on occupational pensions (BVG) and ordinance BVV 2, entry threshold, coordination deduction and age credits
- Accident insurance ordinance (UVV), maximum insured earnings and non-occupational cover
- ESTV circular no. 45 on withholding tax (monthly and annual model)
- ESTV, overview of the withholding tax model per canton (circular no. 45, annex 3)
- ESTV, withholding tax tariffs for payroll systems (TXT, all cantons)
- Federal direct tax act (DBG), Art. 107, which canton withholds the tax